TIME Higgs boson nomination: 5 for 5

I’m probably dating myself here, but I remember when many mainstream magazines, and TV or print news organizations, had actual scientists working for them. Some of them even had “science desks,” which fact-checked and explained science-based stories. That was before two or three megacorporations bought most of the American news infrastructure and began “streamlining” the staff, and before magazines started desperately downsizing to remain profitable.

Now we have embarrassments like this one, in which TIME magazine has nominated the Higgs Boson for its 2012 Person of the Year (in which case they’d have to rename it to Particle of the Year) with the following 5-sentence paragraph:

Take a moment to thank this little particle for all the work it does, because without it, you’d be just inchoate energy without so much as a bit of mass. What’s more, the same would be true for the entire universe. It was in the 1960s that Scottish physicist Peter Higgs first posited the existence of a particle that causes energy to make the jump to matter. But it was not until last summer that a team of researchers at Europe’s Large Hadron Collider — Rolf Heuer, Joseph Incandela and Fabiola Gianotti — at last sealed the deal and in so doing finally fully confirmed Einstein’s general theory of relativity. The Higgs — as particles do — immediately decayed to more-fundamental particles, but the scientists would surely be happy to collect any honors or awards in its stead.

Every single sentence in this paragraph contains at least one error. The third sentence has three. The fourth sentence leads Michael Moyer, writing for Scientific American, to sigh, “Where to begin?”

Moyer’s line-by-line explanation of where TIME went wrong and what the facts really are is worth a read. This was my favorite part:

The photon is the poster child for behaving as both wave (energy) and particle (matter) at the same time.

And Peter Higgs was neither the first nor the only physicist to posit the existence of the particle that bears his name.

And he’s English (born in Newcastle), not Scottish.

You can practically hear the exasperation.


About Fletcher DeLancey

Socialist heathen and Mac-using author of the Chronicles of Alsea, who enjoys pondering science, politics, well-honed satire (though sarcastic humor can work, too) and all things geeky.
This entry was posted in science. Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to TIME Higgs boson nomination: 5 for 5

  1. Cathy White says:

    No comment on the Higgs, only knowledge of it comes courtesy of Big Bang Theory, but, wrap up warm …. It is the Geminids tonight. If you have a clear dark sky look out for what is supposed to be a spectacular display of meteors. I’ve a hip flask and woolly hat and hopefully the clouds will stay away.

  2. Cathy White says:

    Ditto, three times I braved the wind chill, but complete cloud cover spoiled what should have been a brilliant display. I’m really ticked off. On another note, on your tour round the Port distilleries did you come across a Crusted Port? Something different for my brother-in-law for Xmas

  3. Cathy White says:

    Reading from the label…. Crusted Port derives it’s name from the fact that, exactly like Vintage Port, it will throw a ” crust ” or natural deposit as it matures in bottle. It will therefore require a simple decanting prior to serving. Stand the bottle upright a few hours before opening so as to allow the deposit to settle and carefully pour the wine into large clean wine glasses….. Thus endeth the lesson 🙂 It is a W.& J. Graham’s , bottled in 2003. According to the label it won a silver medal in 2011 at the International Wine Challenge.

  4. Ghost says:

    If the incorrect facts were not enough, that entire paragraph is infested with blatant grammatical errors. It leads one to wonder: are editors even editing any longer or is a pass by spellcheck enough qualification?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s