
My family used to toss out the above phrase as a pat response whenever anyone asked a question where the answer was patently and transparently yes. But lately I’ve been wondering if that hasn’t outlived its time. Living in a Catholic nation and speaking with my Catholic friends, I’ve come to the conclusion that the true Catholic Church is not the one represented by the Pope.
The latest disconnect between the two churches came this past week, and can be illustrated with these quotes:
”Initiatives aimed at protecting the essential and primary values of life, beginning at conception, and of the family based on the indissoluble marriage between a man and a woman, help to respond to some of today’s most insidious and dangerous threats to the common good.”
– Pope Benedict, using a May 13 mass at Portugal’s holiest shrine as a platform to influence the nation’s politics, and to label equal marriage an insidious and dangerous threat to society.
“This is a historic moment in Portuguese society. In the past, our nation was a pioneer in such decisive human rights issues as abolishing the death penalty…Portugal can also be a pioneer in the defense of human rights, such as human dignity and the evolution of the individual, and in fighting discrimination, namely that based on sexual orientation.”
– Official statement from the Portuguese government, upon the May 17 passage of equal marriage into law.
I once asked my Portuguese tutor, who is a very devout Catholic, what her thoughts were on equal marriage. If anyone were against it, I believed it would be her. She responded with a snort. “God is love,” she said. “Marriage is a celebration of love. If two people love each other enough to commit to marriage, it is not our place to say they cannot.”
Another friend of mine, who is not Portuguese but is a lifelong and devout Catholic, said simply, “God created us all, and Jesus never turned away from anyone.”
These are not the messages we hear from the Pope, the Vatican, or the hierarchy of the Church. They are, however, the messages offered by many of the parish clergy. They are the messages that are instinctively understood by many of the laity, who base their lives on the Christian ideals of love and acceptance, rather than dogma.
The Vatican has historically stumbled along several hundred years behind the rest of the world, accepting new concepts centuries after everyone else. (It waited 359 years before admitting that Galileo was right.) I wonder, then, why we still think of both the Vatican and the Pope as the leaders of the Church? They are not. The real leaders of the Church are those priests and nuns who devote their lives to offering aid and comfort, and those members of the laity who live by the tenets of love.
If the Pope is Catholic, then his church is not the same church my friends and family belong to. Those Portuguese who celebrated their nation’s stand for equality and human dignity — they are the true Catholics.
Like this:
Be the first to like this post.